How to Find Weaknesses in Your Script

The new screenwriter tends to have a love affair with
is/her "baby." He's married to every word and nuanceIsaac Asimov: "Either it sounds right or it doesn't sound
he's carefully scripted onto each page. Often, it readsright."
more like a novel than a screenplay and usually it
needs a serious rewrite. It's time to get a divorce.You might be amazed at how you'll spot those things
you know need a little extra attention. They're those
You must not be afraid to hack, chisel or cut-outthings that seem "odd" or don't feel "right" to you when
ANYTHING that does not serve to push the storyyou read it out loud. You might find yourself thinking
forward. Sooner or later, you'll write a scene that isthat certain characters say and do things that don't
just plain good. You're in love again and all is right withseem to "fit" their backstory. You likely find this
the world. Finally, you conclude that it doesn't serve theespecially true of dialogue. Circle these dialogue
story as it should. You must get a divorce and hack itpassages so you can come back to them later.
out of the script.
4. Act it out.
Remember: not every story is movie material. Not
every story is as fascinating on the screen as it is inThis is also an opportunity to get actor friends to read
our heads. This is especially true of biographical stories.your script. If scenes are awkward or don't come
As interesting as someone's true-life experiences are,across as you intended, they need work. Stage a
they rarely translate well to the screen. However, itreading of the script. Make sure all of the actors get a
often makes an excellent bestsellinglist of the characters they will portray and have
book.someone assigned to all of the lesser, incidental
characters. Don't prep them! Let the actor get the
In screenwriting, you only have TWO TOOLS toinformation about the character only from the script. If
work with in a screenplay:he doesn't get it, neither will an agent, reader or
producer; and you need to go back the set-up the
DIALOGUE: that characters saycharacter so he DOES get it. During the reading, mark
ACTION: a visual description of what is seen on thescenes that don't work or have the intended impact
movie screenand come back to
them later.
This does NOT include:
5. Read it through out loud again, but only the ACTION
* Anything anyone "knows" (i.e. "Ed heard aboutDESCRIPTION.
Jennifer's problem at school.")
* Anything that cannot be photographed (i.e. "MaryMovies are a visual medium. If your story isn't visual,
loves chocolate ice cream.")maybe it shouldn't be a movie. Did you get lost? Are
* Anything the audience "knows" (i.e. "This is the samethings vague? Are the scenes not visual? Can you tell
woman we saw earlier at the bar.")what's going by the visual clues? Mark those scenes
* Any background information (i.e. "John is Tom's bestand come back and flush them out a little more.
friend.")
* Any action description that uses '-ing' words. (i.e.6. One more time out loud, but this time only the
"Sue is reading the newspaper." should be "Sue readsDIALOGUE.
the newspaper.")
Do characters seem to drone on and on? Can't tell
Here's a common sense approach to self-analysis ofWHAT they're talking about? Do they talk about things
your own screenplay:not essential to the scene? Mark these scenes and
come back and rewrite them later.
1. Read some FIRST-RATE scripts!
Rule of Thumb: Scenes and dialogue should start at
You need outstanding examples of well-writtenthe point where, if you cut out the start of the scene,
screenplays against which you can compare yourwhat follows doesn't make sense any more. This also
work objectively. I recommend you read at least three,applies to movies. Many screenplays really start
preferably nine, screenplays. Here's the catch: Youaround pages 30-50, which means the writer spent
MUST read them ALL in the same week. Agents andway too much time setting up the story. How do you
development executives read 35-50 a week on theirtell? As you read, it suddenly seems as though you've
own time so I know you can read at least three. Don'tstarted a "movie in a movie" and you like it better than
look at a single page of your script until you've finishedthe one you started. Time to get divorced. Unsure?
reading the scripts you downloaded. Read one (orWrite a second script and see which version you like
more) in each of the following categories:best.
* One in the same genre as yours,Writing is Rewriting
* One that's been made into an OSCAR-winning or
nominated movie, andErnest Hemingway: "Don't get discouraged because
* One that's an all-time favorite movie of yours.there's a lot of mechanical work to writing...I rewrote
the first part of Farewell to Arms at least fifty times."
2. Now: read your script.
Paddy Chayefsky: "I'm not a great writer, I'm a great
It might seem a little different now, but that's GOOD.rewriter."
You're becoming a little more objective.
Good advice from two guys who ought to know.
3. Read yours again: OUT LOUD.